Consciousness: Reductive Physicalism to Ultimate Holism

Consciousness: Reductive Physicalism to Ultimate Holism

GAU Journal of Social and Applied Science

Abstract
In the reductive physicalist paradigm in mainstream modern science, consciousness emerges from random bits of energy/matter that bind together from lower-order parts into unitary biological organisms which somehow develop higher-order conscious control over the parts. How the closed causal chain unlinks and inserts a causally efficacious conscious mind is utterly mysterious. Consciousness must be epiphenomenal or non-existent, and thus a fundamental misperception. This paper summarizes a logically consistent alternative that incorporates progress over the past century in quantum, quantum gravity, and unified field theories extending into theorized subtle underlying nonlocal space and further into the ultimate holism of the unified field. Added to the reductionism and physicalism are real, non-local, nonphysical levels of nature. These cutting edge developments – which have profound implications for addressing long-standing dilemmas in modern science such as the mind-body problem – are matching up with the consciousness-mind-matter ontology in the oldest continuous knowledge tradition of Vedic science.

Consciousness: Reductive Physicalism to Ultimate Holism

Is the ‘Big Bang’ a Big Myth?

GAU Journal of Social and Applied Science, 2007

Abstract
Inflationary big bang theory is the consensus model of the origin of the universe in contemporary cosmology. According to this theory, the universe emerged from randomly fluctuating quantum fields that apparently originated instantaneously from nothing. It is further theorized that these quantum fields congealed into stars, planets, and eventually living organisms such as human beings with sufficient neural complexity to generate consciousness. These theories are associated with the reductive, materialistic, bottom-up matter-mind-consciousness ontology still prominent in modern science. In this perspective, consciousness emerges from randomly fluctuating bits of energy/matter, which somehow bind into neural networks that generate conscious mind; and then in some quite mysterious way, conscious mind gains causal power to direct behavior of the whole organism.
This paper describes an alternative, logically consistent, holistic view from ancient Vedic science that is a top-down consciousness-mind-matter ontology. In that holistic view, the source of everything in nature, the unified field, is conscious Being. Remaining within the unified field, nature limits itself or condenses into mind and matter. In the holistic view, the origin of the universe is better characterized as a ‘Big Condensation’ rather than the ‘Big Bang.’ The holistic view is consistent with unified field theories, symmetry breaking, quantum decoherence, the ‘arrow of time,’ and the 2nd law of thermodynamics – all of which imply that the universe originated from the lowest entropy, super-symmetric, perfectly orderly unified field.
Holistic Vedic science provides empirical means to resolve fundamental paradoxes in the reductive materialistic, bottom-up ontology, including the so-called hard problem of consciousness, order emerging from fundamental random disorder, and everything emerging from nothing.

Consciousness: Reductive Physicalism to Ultimate Holism

The Top Down Consciousness-Mind-Matter Ontology

Journal of Consciousness Studies

Abstract
The consensus cosmological theory of the origin of the universe holds that it emerged in a big bang 13.7 billion years ago―apparently from literally nothing. There were no initial conditions, inherent nature, order, purpose, design, or underlying nonphysical existence from which the big bang emerged. In pre-inflationary theory, nothing instantaneously became fundamentally random, inherently dynamic quantized gravity and Higgs fields subject to invariant laws of nature. As the story continues, four fundamental particle-force fields emerged through spontaneous symmetry breaking and congealed into stars, planets, organic molecules, living cellular organisms possibly with proto-conscious mentality, and later into humans with complex enough nervous systems to generate higher-order conscious behavior.
This fragmented, reductive view is associated with a bottom up matter-mind-consciousness ontology. In this view, consciousness is an emergent property of random bits of matter/energy that bind together from lower-order physical processes into higher-order, unitary biological organisms which then develop apparent causal influence on their parts. How the closed chain of cause and effect could unlink itself and insert a conscious observer with causal efficacy in the physical is utterly mysterious. In this view, consciousness must be a powerless epiphenomenon, or be non-existent and thus a fundamental misperception in humans that begs explanation. This view is characteristic of reasoning and sensory experience in the ordinary waking state of consciousness, in which there is a fundamental fragmentation of experience into the outer objective world and inner subjectivity that the reductive physicalist paradigm cannot reconcile.
In contrast, the holistic view in Vedic science is a top down consciousness-mind-matter ontology, in which everything in nature progressively emerges within the perfectly orderly unified field, Atma or pure Being. All phenomenal existence remains within the unified field and condenses through sequential symmetry breaking into manifest creation, from higher order holistic processes to lower-order inert parts. That view is systematically unfolded in Rik Veda, and extensively described in Vedic literature such as Vedanta, Sankhya, and Ayurveda. It is consistent with developing unified field theories, spontaneous sequential symmetry breaking, quantum decoherence, the ‘arrow of time,’ and the 2nd law of thermodynamics that imply the universe emerged from the lowest entropy, supersymmetric unified state.
From that view, the origin of the universe can be characterized as a ‘Big Condensation’ rather than ‘Big Bang,’ because all phenomenal existence remains within the unified field, rather than blasting out from nothing to create everything including space-time. These contrasting reductive and holistic views are reconciled in the natural development of higher states of consciousness beyond the ordinary waking state. The Vedic science of Yoga provides systematic means to validate the consciousness-mind-matter ontology through direct empirical experience of gross and subtle diversified fields of nature and the transcendent unified field that underlies and permeates them.